From collection Creating Acadia National Park: The George B. Dorr Research Archive of Ronald H. Epp

Page 1

Page 2

Page 3

Page 4

Page 5

Page 6

Page 7

Page 8

Page 9

Page 10

Page 11

Page 12

Page 13

Page 14
Search
results in pages
Metadata
Peterson, Charles E.
Peterson Charles E.
Richard H: Quin
CADILLAC MOUNTAIN ROAD
HAER No. ME-58
(page 15)
box culverts and a number of 18" concrete pipe culverts for
38
drainage.
"Guardrails" for the road consisted of large boulder border or
coping stones, about 3' 6" in height. The stones were closely
spaced SO that gaps of only about 4' appeared between them. The
BPR engineer noted they made a "very substantial and pleasing"
effect. 39 Similar border stones had been used on the Rockefeller
carriage roads in the park and on the earlier "Mountain Road"
motor road segment.
Dennis Doonan, dynamite man for the McCabe company, was fatally
injured on the project on 10 September 1929. Doonan had been
anxious to complete the drilling and blasting on a ledge face
near the lower end of the road, and asked two employees to work
overtime on the drilling. As one of the men, Jean Lipscomb, was
drilling a hole, the drill steel snapped off. When he removed it
from the hole, he found it very hot and showed it to Doonan.
Although he had had thirty years experience in blasting work,
Doonan disregarded the overheated steel, and proceeded to load
the hole with a charge. He placed two sticks of dynamite in the
hole, and tamped them down. Nothing happened, but when he added
a third stick with an electric blasting cap, the charge exploded,
injuring Doonan so badly that he died in the hospital the
following morning.4 40 The tragedy did not, however, seriously
delay the project.
On 17 June 1930, BPR District Engineer Guy M. Miller ordered the
extension of the work to the summit. The grading contract was
41
completed on 1 November at a total cost of $154,221.52.
In December, National Park Service Assistant Landscape Architect
Charles E. Peterson came to Acadia to inspect the project for
acceptance. As Peterson later recounted, "I met Grossman on the
summit of the mountain. He was as proud of work as if he had
just completed the Panama canal. I told him it was the worst
piece of landscape damage ever inflicted on a national park. II 42
Peterson was aghast by the lack of project cleanup work. The
38
Ibid., 2-3.
39
Ibid., 3.
40 Grossman, Cadillac Mountain Highway project diary, 10
September 1930. MSS, Acadia National Park Historical Collection.
41Ibid., 2, 4.
42Charles E. Peterson interview, 23 August 1995.
CADILLAC MOUNTAIN ROAD
HAER No. ME-58
(page 16)
contractor had left debris strewn all over the project, and the
blasting had cast stone a considerable distance to either side of
the road. In his report, Peterson recommended against accepting
the project until the contractor removed his truck tires, rub-
bish, and construction equipment and took efforts to clean up the
sidecast stone. Peterson told BPR engineer Miller that the
contractor's general disregard for the blasting restrictions
outlined in the specifications had caused extensive landscape
damage. As McCabe had failed to make any money on the work, he
conceded it would be difficult to have him do any further clean-
up work. Peterson warned Miller that it would be necessary to
place more stringent restrictions in future specifications for
road work in the park. 43
Nothing was evidently done to correct the disfigurement In
September 1931, Peterson put his earlier impressions in writing.
"The contract of the grading work on Cadillac Mountain which was
completed last year constitutes the worst piece of landscape
damage which any road has done in a national park. "> The contrac-
tor had been required to pick up all rock lying outside of the
toe of the slope within a distance of 30' from the road
shoulders, while rock and dead vegetation outside the 30' area
was to be handled by force account. McCabe had completed his
work, but much debris remained. Peterson noted that $11,000 had
been transferred to the Acadia park books for clean-up, but
doubted it would be sufficient for the work. He stated there was
a "crying need" to do something more, especially because of all
the criticism of road-building work in the park and because
the
road would be judged against Rockefeller's excellent work. 44
Peterson also urged the widening of the road in several loca-
tions, especially at major curves, noting that extra grading
would generally not be required. The widening could utilize some
of the waste rock which had been thrown over the edge The only
extra cost would involve relocating several stretches of the
border stones, but he thought they could be eliminated
altogether. He added that the use of guard rail (in this case,
the stones) was "greatly in excess of that which we regularly
follow in Park work," in some cases being employed on the insides
of curves. He recommended that where the road needed widening,
43
3Charles E. Peterson, Assistant Landscape Architect, Branch
of Plans and Design, National Park Service, to Guy M. Miller,
District Engineer, Bureau of Public Roads, 20 December 1930,
attached to Ibid.
44 Idem, "Memorandum for the Director No. 1: Clean-up on the
Cadillac Mountain Road, 26 September 1931. National Archives,
Record Group 79, Central Classified Files.
CADILLAC MOUNTAIN ROAD
HAER No. ME-58
(page 17)
the stones should simply be tipped over into the ditch and
covered up. Any extra widened areas would be used by motorists,
he felt, because "fine views are to be had at nearly all points."
He urged the BPR be directed to submit an estimate for this work,
and that it be carried out as soon as possible. 45
Another criticism Peterson noted was inadequate parking at the
summit, which consisted only of a widened space below the
terminal loop. He thought a main parking area should be
constructed inside the loop, and the existing area designated for
overflow. The loop was one of the areas "devastated" by the
excessive blasting, and placing the parking here would concen-
trate the damage in one spot. Along with the other work,
Peterson felt the parking area should be constructed before the
road opened the following summer. He added that as the parking
area and loop lay in a saddle below a short rise, visitors would
want to leave their cars and walk around to take in the views.
Accordingly, he suggested the construction of a system of trails
around the summit. To determine their location, he urged that
the BPR topographic map of the summit be expanded so that the
location of the trails, as well as the desired tea house, could
be chosen. The trails, he believed, should be 4' 6" wide and
paved with crushed rock. Their surfacing could use some more of
the excess rock lying along the road. He insisted that all of
the work on the mountain should be done under the supervision of
a Park Service landscape architect in order to avoid such
46
problems as had previously been encountered.
With the grading project complete, the BPR prepared designs and
specifications for the subsequent surfacing project. The Bureau
of Public Roads had initially decided to surface the road with a
bituminous macadam using emulsified asphalt as a binder.
However, an inspection of an experimental stretch of this
surfacing at Dedham, Massachusetts showed such surfacing did not
hold up well, being "shot to pieces" only five months after it
had been laid. Rather than risking similar failure on the
Cadillac Mountain project, BPR engineers decided to utilize
"Pentolithic" macadam. The specifications called for a 22'
45
Idem, "Memorandum for the Director No. 2: Special
Widenings for the Cadillac Mountain Road, 11 26 September 1931.
National Archives, Record Group 79, Central Classified Files.
46
Idem, "Memorandum for the Director No. 3: Parking Area on
the Summit of Cadillac Mountain," 26 September 1931; "Memorandum
for the Director No. 4: Path on the Summit of Cadillac Mountain,
26 September 1931. National Archives, Record Group 79, Central
Classified Files.
Charles E. Peterson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Page 1 of 7
Charles E. Peterson
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Charles Emil Peterson (1906-2004) is widely considered to be a seminal figure in professionalizing
the practice of historic preservation in the United States. He is referred to as the "founding father" of the
professional advocation of historic preservation,
[1]
the "godfather of preservation,
and
an
"extraordinary preservationist"- who made important contributions to the knowledge of early American
building practices, helped create the profession of the preservation architect, and passionately advocated
for the retention and restoration of the American built heritage. According to Jacques Dalibard, a
professor at McGill University School of Architecture, "with James Marston Fitch, [4] I cannot think
of
two people who had more influence on historic preservation in North America.
"[5]
During his long career, Peterson received numerous awards for his service including the National Trust
for Historic Preservation's Louise du Pont Crowninshield Award (1966) and the American Institute of
Architects (AIA) medal for "vision and determination" (1979) and the Presidential Citation (1990). The
AIA inducted him into the College of Fellows in 1962.
[6][7]
Contents
1 Early career
2 Early Philadelphia era
3 Career highlights
4 Creation of the profession of the preservation architect
5 Legacy
6 Notes
7 Further reading
Early career
Peterson was raised in Madison, Minnesota, and received his bachelor's degree in architecture in the
early 1920s from the University of Minnesota. [2][6] In 1929, he began a thirty-three year tenure with the
National Park Service. [6][7]:5 In 1931, his efforts were instrumental in saving the Moore House, the site of
the British surrender, in Yorktown, Virginia. While documenting this building, Peterson created the
prototype for the historic structure report, the basic format of which is still in use. [6][8]
Peterson is perhaps best remembered for establishing the Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS),
a federal documentation program that is still active and which has spawned the Historic American
Engineering Record and the Historic American Landscape Survey. On November 13, 1933, while he
was the Chief of the Eastern Division for the National Park Service, Peterson wrote a memo to the
director which became the charter for the program and successfully garnered funds from the Civil
Works Administration the following month. HABS targeted unemployed architects, draftsmen, and
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Peterson
2/9/2016
Charles E. Peterson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Page 2 of 7
photographers to make as complete a record as possible of "the rapidly disappearing examples of early
architecture and historic structures throughout the country." This program was credited as "the first
major step upon the part of the Federal Government toward the cataloging and preservation of historic
structures.
",[2][9]:1[10]
The first HABS survey work began in January 1934 and later that year was
formalized as a joint agreement with the American Institute of Architects and the Library of Congress.
[9]:2
The HABS program has continued nearly unabated to the present. [11]
During his life, Peterson constantly advocated for HABS, and was instrumental in restarting the program
in 1957 and later saved it from oblivion when the Reagan administration threatened to pull funding. The
end result was a stronger program with greatly increased funding. [12]
Early Philadelphia era
Peterson and NPS historian Roy E. Appelman were assigned to Philadelphia in early 1947 to advise the
Philadelphia National Shrines Park Commission on the national park being proposed for the area
surrounding Independence Hall. Peterson was the uncredited primary author and editor of the Shrines
Commission's 7-volume final report to Congress (December 1947), which was incorporated into the
enabling legislation under which Independence National Historical Park was created.
Peterson returned to Philadelphia in the early 1950s to work at INHP. While there, he helped restore
Carpenters' Hall and re-create Library Hall, and directed much of the preservation-related activity of the
National Park Service in the region. It was in this era that the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
demolished all the 19th- and early 20th-century buildings on the 3 blocks north of Independence Hall, to
create an open European-style mall. (Independence Mall remained a state park until 1974.) Peterson
oversaw the moving of the Free Quaker Meetinghouse, the only building spared in the creation of the
Mall, to accommodate the widening of 5th Street. He opposed the demolition of important 19th-century
buildings within INHP, but did not prevail. He retired from the National Park Service in 1962, but
continued to live and work from his row house located on Spruce Street.
[1][2][6][13]
During Peterson's
tenure at the National Park Service, he educated numerous students about historic preservation. [14]
In the 1950s, Philadelphia was in decline and the oldest neighborhoods, dating to the 18th century, were
being abandoned and left to decay. It was in such a place that Peterson decided to purchase two row
homes in 1954, one of which became his home. The area, which is now known as "Society Hill," is
today one of the most desirable areas to live in Philadelphia. Peterson not only helped name the area, but
his tireless preservation advocacy secured the revitalization of Society Hill by motivating his friends and
acquaintances to buy property there. [1][6]
Career highlights
The 1960s were an extremely productive time for Peterson. He contributed to many scholarly
conferences, including the Second International Congress of Architects and Technicians of Historical
Monuments in Venice in 1964. It was at this conference that the enormously influential Venice Charter
was created, which established much of preservation philosophy that exists to this day and has become
ingrained in the National Park Service's Secretary of the Interior's Standards for preservation. Peterson,
along with the entire U.S. delegation rejected the charter, however, due to its European focus and the
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Peterson
2/9/2016
Charles E. Peterson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Page 3 of 7
radical emphasis on preservation instead of restoration. [15][16] In the 1960s, restoration-defined as the
"scraping" of later layers of historic fabric in order to restore the appearance of a building to an arbitrary
date-was the status quo and represented the majority of preservation work in the United States. The
Venice Charter was a radical shift in preservation philosophy that would not become fully accepted in
the United States until the 1980s. Peterson also served on the Committee on Principles and Guidelines
for Historic Preservation established by the National Trust which helped influence the future direction of
the preservation movement. [17]
In the mid-1960s, Peterson was appointed as an adjunct professor to the fledgling historic preservation
program at Columbia University where he taught early-American building technology. He worked
closely with James Marston Fitch to build this program into the first graduate degree program in historic
preservation in the country. [18][19] Columbia's program became the model which spawned the tens of
graduate and undergraduate programs in historic preservation that now exist across the United States. In
1970, Peterson established the European Traveling Summer School for Restorationists that allowed
architects to view and participate in restoration projects outside the United States.
[20]
Peterson was a founding member of the Association for Preservation Technology (APT) which was
created in 1968 in an effort to provide better education for the restoration, documentation, and
preservation of historic buildings. He became the organization's first president in 1969. [2][3] APT was
enormously influential as it represented the first scholarly outlet for the activities of historic
preservation. Peterson's activities through APT helped move preservation from an antiquarian hobby to
a professional endeavor.
Throughout his career, Peterson was an avid researcher on the history of American building technology.
He is best known for his work on Robert Smith, [7][21] a colonial-era architect which culminated in the
publication of his book Robert Smith (1722-1777): Architect, Builder and Patriot by The Athenaeum of
Philadelphia and the Carpenters' Company of Philadelphia in 2000. Other topics that Peterson covered
included the early architecture of the Mississippi River valley, the use of iron in roofs, the development
of the I-beam, and the recovery of the "lost" history of cement and concrete construction. [22]
In 1983, Peterson established the Charles E. Peterson Prize to be awarded to students displaying superior
drawing abilities in documenting HABS buildings. Managed by The Athenaeum of Philadelphia, the
prize is awarded by HABS, the Athenaeum, and the AIA. [2][7] He also donated all of his research papers
and books to the University of Maryland in 1998, having in 1981 endowed a substantial fund to support
scholarly research in American Architecture prior to 1860 at The Athenaeum of Philadelphia and gifted
his Archive and Library of Early American Building Technology and Historic Preservation.
[23][24]
Peterson is credited as an architect of Colonial National Historical Park, Jamestown and Yorktown,
Virginia, listed on the National Register of Historic Places (2)
Creation of the profession of the preservation architect
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Peterson
2/9/2016
Charles E. Peterson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Page 4 of 7
According to many contemporary preservation architects, Peterson "almost singlehandedly invented and
developed the profession of historical architect. ,22] In a similar vein he is considered to be "the father of
modern
restoration
techniques. [27] From his start with the National Park Service in the 1930s, Peterson
continually advocated for training of architects in the proper restoration of buildings that respected their
history, technology, and authenticity. A continual theme of his was the inadequacy of most architects'
work on historic buildings:
The shortcomings of architects in the field of historical restoration began long ago. It
became clear, even in the days of Latrobe, that the most talented designers could not always
be trusted around important landmarks. Some of our most stylish architects have
proposed-and have carried out-gruesome butcheries on historic buildings. The
architectural profession should police its own ranks, if for no reason than that many laymen
have done their homework in history (as a hobby) and are today well ahead of architects.
[28]:2
Peterson explained that there are very few people who understand older buildings and how they are
constructed and "as a result, things happen to historic buildings that should not happen to a
doghouse. "[28]:4
Architects could not simply learn from books and drawings, but had to experience an old building in all
its unrestored, disheveled, shabbiness: "The man who doesn't get his hands dirty on the job will never
know enough. "[10] Peterson's work in this regard has helped spawn innumerable training programs for
architects, such as that offered by the Heritage Conservation Network, that provide hands-on training on
a wide variety of techniques from documentation to pointing with lime mortar.
Legacy
Peterson's legacy can be summed up by his tireless efforts to establish historic preservation as a
professional endeavor. He made essential contributions to how old buildings should be documented and
architects trained. Every holder of a degree in historic preservation should also credit Peterson for the
origins of their education. Lastly, Peterson established a scholarly basis for building interventions. No
longer was an antiquarian aesthetic ethic acceptable for historic preservation; all work had to be
documented and changes well substantiated with historical records.
[29]
Notes
1. Ferrick, Tom, Jr. (September 8, 2004). "He Gave New Life to What Was Old". Philadelphia Inquirer.
2. "Charles E. Peterson, FAIA, Godfather of Historic Preservation". AIArchitect. August 27, 2004.
3.
Waite, Diana S. (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 2.
JSTOR 40004675.
4. James Marston Fitch created the historic preservation program at Columbia University in the 1960s.
5. Dalibard, Jacques (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 3.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Peterse
2/9/2016
Charles E. Peterson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Page 5 of 7
6. Sims, Ronan Gayle (August 20, 2004). "Charles E. Peterson, 97, Preservationist". Philadelphia Inquirer.
7. "Charles E. Peterson, FAPT, FAIA, FSAH (1906-2004)". APT Communiqué 33 (3). 2004.
8. McDonald, Travis (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 4.
9. National Park Service (1936). Historic American Buildings Survey. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government
Printing Office.
10. Peterson, Charles E. (2004). "Charles E. Peterson, FAIA". In Burns, John A. Recording Historic Structures.
Hoboken, N.J.: John Wiley & Sons. p. viii.
11. The HABS project was discontinued during World War II and restarted in the late 1950s.
12. Kapsch, Robert (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 3.
13. Gianopolis, Nicholas (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 3.
14. Massey, James C. (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 4.
15. Gray, Gordon (1967). Historic Preservation Tomorrow. Washington, D.C.: National Trust for Historic
Preservation.
16. Miller, Hugh C. (2006). "Preservation Technology Comes of Age in North America: Part I". APT Bulletin 37
(1): 55. JSTOR 40004681.
17. Committee on Principles and Guidelines for Historic Preservation in the United States (1964). A Report on
Principles and Guidelines for Historic Preservation in the United States (Report). Washington, D.C.: National
Trust for Historic Preservation. p. 3.
18. Peterson, Charles E. (1964). "Restoration: An Emerging Profession". Building Research 1 (5): 5.
19. DeLony, Eric (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 3.
20. Boucher, Jack E. (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 2.
21. Thompson, Maria M. (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 5.
22. Representative examples include: "Early Ste. Genevieve and Its Architecture," Missouri Historical Review
25, no. 2 (1941); "Iron in Early American Roofs," Smithsonian Journal of History (1968); "Inventing the
I-Beam: Richard Turner, Cooper and Hewitt and Others," APT Bulletin 12, no. 4 (1980).
23. "Charles E. Peterson papers". Retrieved July 19, 2013.
24. "Charles E. Peterson Has Established". College & Research Libraries News 59 (7): 536. 1998.
25. Staff (2010-07-09). "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National
Park Service.
26. Waite, John G. (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 5.
27. Greiff, Constance (2006). "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004". APT Bulletin 37 (1): 3.
28. Peterson, Charles E. (1976). "The Role of the Architect in Historical Restorations". In Timmons, Sharon.
Preservation and Conservation: Principles and Practices; Proceedings of the North American International
Regional Conference Williamsburg, Virginia, and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, September 10-16, 1972.
Washington, D.C.: The Preservation Press.
29. Roger W Moss, "Charles E. Peterson," Athenaeum Profiles: A Not-for-Profit-Education | New Castle, Del.|
Oak Knoll Press, 2008| pp. 45-56.
Further reading
Boucher, Jack E. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1 (2006):
2.
"Charles E. Peterson Has Established." College & Research Libraries News 59, no. 7 (1998): 536.
"Charles E. Peterson, FAIA, Godfather of Historic Preservation." AIArchitect (Aug 27, 2004).
"Charles E. Peterson, FAPT, FAIA, FSAH (1906-2004)." APT Communiqué 33, no. 3 (2004): 5.
Committee on Principles and Guidelines for Historic Preservation in the United States. A Report
on Principles and Guidelines for Historic Preservation in the United States. Washington, D.C.:
National Trust for Historic Preservation, 1964.
Dalibard, Jacques. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1
(2006): 2.
DeLony, Eric. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1 (2006): 3.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Peterson
2/9/2016
Charles E. Peterson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Page 6 of 7
Ferrick, Tom, Jr. "He Gave New Life to What Was Old." Philadelphia Inquirer, September 8,
2004.
Gianopolis, Nicholas. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1
(2006): 3.
Gray, Gordon. Historic Preservation Tomorrow. Washington, D.C.: National Trust for Historic
Preservation, 1967.
Greiff, Constance. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1
(2006): 3.
Kapsch, Robert. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1 (2006):
3.
Massey, James C. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1 (2006):
4.
McDonald, Travis. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1
(2006): 4.
Miller, Hugh C. "Preservation Technology Comes of Age in North America: Part I." APT Bulletin
37, no. 1 (2006): 55-59.
Moss, Roger W. "Charles E. Peterson," Athenaeum Profiles: A Not-for-Profit Education New
Castle, Del.: Oak Knoll Press, 2014.
National Park Service. Historic American Buildings Survey. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government
Printing Office, 1936.
Peterson, Charles E. "Restoration: An Emerging Profession." Building Research 1, no. 5 (1964):
5.
Peterson, Charles E. "The Role of the Architect in Historical Restorations." In Preservation and
Conservation: Principles and Practices; Proceedings of the North American International *
Regional Conference Williamsburg, Virginia, and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, September 10-16,
1972, edited by Sharon Timmons, 1-11. Washington, D.C.: The Preservation Press, 1976.
Peterson, Charles E. "Charles E. Peterson, FAIA." In Recording Historic Structures, edited by
John A Burns, viii-ix. Hoboken, N.J.: John Wiley & Sons, 2004.
Sims, Ronan Gayle. "Charles E. Peterson, 97, Preservationist." Philadelphia Inquirer, August 20,
2004.
Thompson, Maria M. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1
(2006): 5.
Waite, Diana S. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1 (2006):
2.
Waite, John G. "In Memory of Charles E. Peterson, 1906-2004." APT Bulletin 37, no. 1 (2006): 5.
Retrieved from"https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Charles_E._Peterson&oldid=687816828
Categories: 1906 births
2004 deaths
University of Minnesota alumni
People from Lac qui Parle County, Minnesota American architects Preservationist architects
Fellows of the American Institute of Architects
This page was last modified on 27 October 2015, at 22:34.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms
may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is
a
registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_E._Peterson
2/9/2016
8/28/2021
Preserving Philadelphia: A Conversation with Charles E. Peterson, F.A.I.A. - Pennsylvania Heritage Magazine
PENNSYLV.ANIA
HERITAGE
Home
About
Highlights
Past Issues
Topics
Features
Authors
Home >>
Preserving Philadelphia: A Conversation
with Charles E. Peterson, F.A.I.A.
Written by William Kashatus in the Interview category and the Fall 1998 issue Topics in
this article: architecture and architects, Bank of the United States, Benner-Walker House,
Bishop William White House, Carpenters' Hall, Charles E. Peterson, Christ Church
(Philadelphia), Colonial Williamsburg, Dilworth-Todd-Moylan House, Historic
American Buildings Survey (HABS), historic preservation, Independence Hall.
Independence National Historical Park, John Torrey, John Torrey House, Judge Edwin O.
Lewis, Kaufman Farm, Kid House, Library Hall, Mcllvaine House, National Park
Service, Oley Valley, Penn Mutual buildings, Peters House Hotel, Philadelphia,
Philadelphia Broad Street Station, Philadelphia Merchant's Exchange, photography,
Richard Woodward House, Robert Smith, Samuel Ankrim Shop, Second Bank of the
United States, William and Frederick Langenheim
paheritage.wpengine.com/article/preserving-philadelphia-conversation-charles-e-peterson/
1/13
8/28/2021
Preserving Philadelphia A Conversation with Charles E. Peterson, F.A.I.A. - Pennsylvania Heritage Magazine
Interview is a series of discussions with renowned Pennsylvanians - artists, athletes,
authors, historians, musicians, politicians, scholars, television celebrities and others -
that have appeared occasionally as features in Pennsylvania Heritage.
Gmail
Google Bookmark
Facebook
Twitter
More
1
Those who know Philadelphia realize that it is an enormously important city with an
illustrious, prestigious past. By many it is called the birthplace of a nation, by others the
cradle of liberty. The United States was created in Philadelphia on July 4, 1776, when the
Second Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence. The principles of
the American Revolution were perpetuated in the port city on September 17, 1787, when
the Federal Convention forged the Constitution and referred it, through Congress, to the
individual states for ratification. Both landmark events took place in the Assembly Room
of Pennsylvania's State House, a familiar edifice known today as Independence Hall.
Since 1951, the historic building has been maintained as the centerpiece of Independence
National Historical Park, an urban park which now encompasses six square blocks of
government buildings, restored homes, venerable churches, a portrait gallery, even an
operating tavern. Historical precedent for Independence Park had been set twenty-five
years earlier when oil company heir and philanthropist John D. Rockefeller Jr. (1874-
1960) financed the restoration and reconstruction of Colonial Williamsburg in Virginia,
the most noted historical reconstruction project in America at the time.
Charles E. Peterson, F.A.I.A., of Philadelphia, who played a key role in the development
of Independence National Historical Park, began his career as a restoration planner at
Colonial National Historical Park in Virginia. His informal contacts with the staff at
nearby Williamsburg enabled him to note their research techniques, interdisciplinary col-
laboration, and thorough documentation of that restoration project. Later, during the
formative years of Independence Park, Peterson built on the models of Williamsburg and
similar historic restorations of the 1930s. His gift is reflected in Independence Park's
ability to re-create an eighteenth-century atmosphere by upholding the integrity of the
historic structures within its boundaries while also respecting and reinforcing the urban
character of the neighborhood.
A preservationist and teacher by nature and a militant evangelist for saving old buildings
by profession, Peterson joined the National Park Service in 1929 and quickly became its
leading expert on historical architecture. Four years later, he organized the Historic
American Buildings Survey (HABS) as a cooperative project of the National Park
Service, the American Institute of Architects, and the Library of Congress. Originally
created to provide work for hundreds of unemployed architects during the Great Depres-
sion, HABS has, over the years, become the largest architectural archive of its kind in the
paheritage.wpengine.com/article/preserving-philadelphia-conversation-charles-e-peterson/
2/13
8/28/2021
Preserving Philadelphia: A Conversation with Charles E. Peterson, F.A.I.A. - Pennsylvania Heritage Magazine
world. It has also served as a training agency for young architects, introducing them to
historic structures as well as to restoration techniques on the cutting edge.
The first comprehensive federal program to survey and document American architecture,
HABS has, since its founding, recorded more than twenty-five thousand buildings and
structures throughout the United States and in the Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico, and the
Panama Canal Zone. Pennsylvania claims the distinction of having the greatest number
of sites - more than sixteen hundred - documented by HABS. Information compiled by
HABS teams consists of measured drawings, photographs, and written data spanning
four centuries of construction and covering all types and styles of buildings and
structures, such as log houses, state capitols, covered bridges, skyscrapers, smokehouses,
factories, and even bridges. The HABS collection is one of the most extensively used
collections at the Library of Congress, where it is archived, and includes approximately
fifty thousand sheets of drawings, one hundred and thirty thousand photographs, and
seventy-two thousand pages of written data.
Since HABS began its documentation of the built environment, fully one-third of all
recorded sites have vanished, primarily through demolition for urban expansion or for
better roads and highways and destruction by neglect. These buildings, however, have
been "preserved" by HABS documentation. Through the years HABS has often worked
closely with colleges and universities, including the University of Pennsylvania in the
1950s, and in the following decade with the Carnegie Institute of Technology, Pittsburgh,
and Moravian College in Bethlehem. In order to make HABS records available to the
public, a series of catalogs has been issued to guide researchers through the collection,
beginning in 1938 with the first national catalog. HABS material is frequently used to
illustrate history, architecture, and historic preservation books, catalogs, pamphlets, and
guidebooks. And it all began with Peterson who, in a November 13, 1933, memorandum
to the Director of the Park Service, proposed the national architectural survey.
During his career with the National Park Service, Peterson pioneered new construction
programs at several National Parks, including Colonial ini Virginia, Acadia in Maine,
Jefferson National Expansion Memorial in Missouri, the Great Smokies in North
Carolina and Tennessee, and Hot Springs in Arkansas. His last government posts were as
resident architect of the Independence Park and Supervising Architect for Historic
Structures in the eastern United States, a post he held from 1956 to 1962. Peterson has
been a tireless advocate for local preservation and an advisor to private, public, and
educational projects from Hawaii and Easter Island to Morocco and Turkey.
Among Peterson's impressive list of credentials are Fellow of the American Institute of
Architects (F.A.I.A.), past president of the Society of Architectural Historians, past
president of the Association for Preservation Technology, Benjamin Franklin Fellow of
the Royal Society of Arts, and Fellow of the Newcomen Society in Great Britain. In
paheritage.wpengine.com/article/preserving-philadelphia-conversation-charles-e-peterson/
3/13
Welcome back HABS, HAER
The Bellows Falls Bridge over the Connecticut River in Vermont was built in
A line drawing of the historic lighthouse and residence at St. Croix Island
1905. Scheduled for replacement HAER recorded the bridge in 1979.
National Monument in Maine in Acadia NP.
By Isabel Hill
professional photographs, and historic
Throughout the years, HABS and HAER
Writer-Editor, HAER, WASO
data. Summer teams of student
have trained over 2,000 professionals in
architects, historians, and engineers,
the fields of architecture, history,
Two well-established Federal
under the supervision of HABS and
architectural history, and engineering.
preservation programs, the Historic
HAER professionals, are formed to
The staff of HABS and HAER
American Buildings Survey (HABS) and
document these historic structures.
represents the disciplines of
the Historic American Engineering
Over the years HABS and HAER have
architecture, history, photography and
Record (HAER), have rejoined the Park
amassed the largest collection of quality
engineering. Most have Master's or
Service with the announcement of the
documentation of its kind in the United
Doctoral degrees. Some HABS and
merger of Heritage Conservation and
States; the collection consists of more
HAER employees have won national
Recreation Service units into the
than 20,000 structures, 40,000 sheets of
recognition; for example HABS
National Park Service. HABS is the
drawings, 68,000 photographs, and
photographer Jack Boucher, who was
oldest of these two programs, having
30,000 data pages. This information is
recently awarded the American Institute
been formed within the National Park
made available to the public through the
of Architects medal for his outstanding
Service in 1933 to record examples of
Library of Congress, Division of Prints
contributions to the field of architectural
historic architecture throughout the
and Photographs. A recent study
photography.
United States. The HABS program was
indicates that the HABS and HAER
According to the chief of the National
founded by a tripartite agreement
collections are extremely well
Architectural and Engineering Record,
among the National Park Service, the
utilized-last year over 17,000 items
Robert Kapsch, the future of HABS and
American Institute of Architects, and
were reproduced from the collection for
HAER looks bright under the Park
the Library of Congress. HAER is the
private use. In addition to the Library of
Service. Kapsch intends to emphasize
newer of these two programs, having
Congress, approximately 110 other
the recording of National Historic
been founded within the National Park
libraries throughout the United States
Landmarks, particularly those
Service in 1969 by a tripartite agreement
maintain the HABS and HAER
endangered, and the recording of Park
among the National Park Service, the
collections in whole or substantial part.
Service managed cultural resources to
American Society of Civil Engineers,
This figure is expected to increase in the
HABS and HAER standards.
and the Library of Congress. HAER is
near future as the collections are
Now that these programs are back
the sister program to HABS and was
microfiched and made available to the
with the Park Service, managers are
formed to record examples of historic
public and to institutions.
working on a suitable celebration for the
engineering and industrial archeology
HABS and HAER are unusual
50th anniversary of HABS to be held in
throughout the Nation. Together, the
Government programs in that
1983. They are exploring the feasibility
HABS and HAER programs are
substantial funds are made available by
of developing a computerized data base
organized under the National
private and other public entities to
for the records and are working with
Architectural and Engineering Record.
conduct the recording projects. Last
the U.S. Postal Service to explore the
HABS and HAER record structures
year, for example, approximately one
possibility of issuing a stamp to
through the use of measured drawings,
half of the operating budget of $1.7
commemorate the HABS anniversary.
million for the two programs came from
private donations, or from other entities
of Federal, State, or local government.
4
Viewer Controls
Toggle Page Navigator
P
Toggle Hotspots
H
Toggle Readerview
V
Toggle Search Bar
S
Toggle Viewer Info
I
Toggle Metadata
M
Zoom-In
+
Zoom-Out
-
Re-Center Document
Previous Page
←
Next Page
→
Peterson, Charles E.
Details
Series 2