From collection Creating Acadia National Park: The George B. Dorr Research Archive of Ronald H. Epp

Page 1

Page 2

Page 3

Page 4

Page 5

Page 6

Page 7

Page 8

Page 9

Page 10

Page 11

Page 12

Page 13

Page 14

Page 15

Page 16

Page 17

Page 18

Page 19

Page 20

Page 21

Page 22

Page 23

Page 24

Page 25

Page 26

Page 27

Page 28
Search
results in pages
Metadata
HCTPR Woodlawn-Black House
H. C. T.P.
Woodlaws/BleakHouse
P.O. Box 1478
WOODLAWN
Phone, 207/667-8671
Ellsworth, ME 04605
Fax: 207/667-7950
M S E M
The Black House
"Woodlawn, including the land, buildings,
furniture, and pictures therein shall
be kept as a public park"
-George Nixon Black, Jr.
December 8, 2001
Dr. Ronald H. Epp
2500 North River Road
Manchester, NH 03106-1045
Dear Ronald,
Thank you for becoming a new member of the Woodlawn Museum/The Black
House on December 7,2001. Your membership at the Individual Level will help
Woodlawn reach many of its goals presently and in the future. People like you
are SO important to the future success of the museum. We hope that many others
will join you in the campaign to realize our vision of a museum that is more
responsive to the community's needs, celebrates our rich cultural heritage, and
assures future generations the benefit of George Nixon Black's wonderful gift to
the region.
Your membership entitles you to admission to the museum for tours of the
house and outbuildings, to view the collection and to hear from our guides
about the legacy of the Black Family and their influence upon the financial,
cultural, and political development of the region. Additional benefits at the
Individual Level are outlined on the sheet that accompanies this letter and your
membership cards.
The trustees, the staff, and the volunteers of the Woodlawn Museum thank you
for becoming a member and look forward to your continued support.
With Warmest Regards,
Ron,
The
Sorry I missed seems
you off. Let us know it we
Joshua Campbell Torrance
Executive Director
can be of more help.
Thank you for becoming
a Member!
Josh Torrane
This letter is an official receipt. Your gift is tax
deducible in the extent permitted by law. No goods
or services were offered or provided to you in
exchange for your gift.
file://Untitled
Director of Libraries
200 Bloomfield Avenue
University of Hartford
William H. Mortensen Library
West Hartford, CT 06117-1599
Phone
860.768.4268
Fax
860.768.4274
Email repp@mail.hartford.edu
17 January 2001
CAT
To Whom It May Concern:
I am trying to establish contact with someone representing the Hancock County Trustees of Public
Reservations.
I am engaged in research regarding Goerge Burnham Dorr and his role--with Charles Eliot--in
establishing the Trustees. I would like to determine whether the early years of the Trustees are
documented and--if so--where these records are located. The Maine State Library is unable to provide
a lead to the current Trustees or the presumed documentation.
I am working with the National Park Service, the Jesup Library, the Bar Harbor Historical Society,
and the curator at Acadia National Park Library.
Any assistance that you could provide would be much appreciated.
Sincerely,
Ronald H. Epp, Ph.D.
Director of Libraries
University of Hartford
West Hartford, CT 06117
c/o Trustees
P.O. Box 178
Elloworth, Marie 04605
1 of 1
1/18/01 2:01 PM
Colonel John Black Mansion - Ellsworth, near Bar Harbor and Acadia National Park
wysiwyg://30/http://www.ellsworthme.org/cbmm/index.html
The Colonel Black Mansion
"Woodlawn"
P.O. Box 1478
Route 172 (Surry Road), Ellsworth, Maine (207)667-8671
Near the Bar Harbor and Acadia National Park Area
email: museum@downeast.net
Located in Ellsworth, Maine, and situated amidst stately pine, hemlock, spruce and
horsechestnut trees sits "Woodlawn," " the 300 acre estate of the Colonel John Black
family. The graceful brick mansion, positioned for an expansive view, was built between
1824 and 1828. It was the home of Colonel and Mrs. Black and their children and also
contained an office from which John Black managed his lumber business and dealings as
land agent for the vast holdings of the William Bingham estate.
Colonel Black's wealth allowed the family to import such fine furnishings as Queen
Anne, Chippendale, Jacobean and Sheraton. The sizable butler's pantry is stocked with
beautiful china and glassware such as Canton, Spode, Staffordshire, Waterford and
Sandwich. Among the items of historical significance are a rare volume of Massachusetts
Colonial Law, a miniature of George Washington presented to Mary Black's father,
General David Cobb, after the close of The Revolutionary War. Although the home houses
many museum quality antiques, clocks, art work, textiles and china, visitors find
themselves drawn into the atmosphere of intimate family life during the early 19th century.
Woodlawn was bequeathed to the public in 1928 by George Nixon Black, Jr.,
grandson of Colonel Black. The home remains as the family left it, dignified yet
comfortable, enticing visitors to linger and enjoy the peaceful atmosphere. One might
choose to visit the Carriage Houses with several rare and interesting carriages and sleighs,
stroll through the Formal Gardens, sip tea on the lush Tea Lawn, walk the Horse Trails
originally used to exercise the Blacks' horses, or browse in the Gift Shop. Whatever way
you choose to spend your time at Woodlawn, you will come away with a renewed sense of
appreciation for an era gone by.
A pleasant drive from any section of Maine, Woodlawn is located near downtown
1 of 3
1/18/01 2:11 PM
^unily documents received
RONALD EPP
9/15/2020 3:51 PM
Re: documents received
To steve@gsmassoc.org
Steve,
I
compared what I sent you against seven other documents that I now
know I did not send you. All of the unsent concern a three month period
(Feb. to April 1915) where Eliot-Dorr-and JDRJr. are negotiating the
Dorr-Eliot request from JDRJr. of $17,500 to help cover the cost of
clearing deeds as part of the federal government requirements for
national monument status which they will secure the next year.
What is interesting here is that this is their first effort at working together.
Yet at the very first letter from Jr. on page 1 he states: "Should this
monument be created, what would be the situation with reference to
roads made or to be made through the valleys that would then be a part
of the monument? Who would care for them? What, if any, restrictions
would there be on them with reference to their use by automobiles. "
You get the drift. He has forced Dorr-Eliot to consider what I believe had
not been given much attention by either of them. Kln the last letter Eliot
makes clear that to Dorr that Jr. always takes care of #1 in his land
negotiations: "You perceive that in this way of transacting business one
gets no record of Mr. Rockefeller's action."
Send or not?
Ron
Ronald H. Epp, Ph.D.
7 Peachtree Terrace
Farmington, CT 06032
603-491-1760
eppster2@comcast.net
On 09/15/2020 10:20 AM steve@gsmassoc.org wrote:
https://connect.xfinity.com/appsuite/v=7.10.3-6.20200722.054552/print.html?print_1600199552473
1/2
The Woodlawn Museum, an Extended History
Page 1 of 7
WOODLAWN
M
The Black House
WOODLAWN- AN ESTATE OF HISTORY
Woodlawn Museum (the Black House) stands as a testimony to the exceptional accomplishments of
Colonel John Black. However, its true significance can be grasped only in the context of major
developments which comprise much of Maine's history, especially that of Down East Maine in the nearly
one hundred years following the onset of the American Revolution. It is a history of which Col. Black is a
major author.
Still a part of Massachusetts at the end of that war, Maine was characterized by an abundance of natural
resources-coastline, woodlands, and rivers. Yet, other than Native Americans, it could claim but few
settlers, by necessity stouthearted individuals who managed to eke out an existence on the water, in the
woods, or out of the soil.
The need for money was the impetus that caused Massachusetts in 1786 to institute a lottery to
encourage settlements in the eastern sections of Maine, subsequently to be referred to as the Kennebec
(large portions of today's Somerset County) and Penobscot (the current areas of Hancock and
Washington Counties) tracts. This effort's failure to translate Maine lands into money occasioned a
renewed attempt-- but also unsuccessful-to sell townships to those Massachusetts citizens of means.
In 1791, real land speculation took off. Henry Knox and William Duer, both well-known Americans,
completed with the Massachusetts Land Committee a highly-leveraged deal to purchase the above-
referenced two tracts of land, roughly one million acres each, at approximately 10 cents per acre. Their
efforts to find buyers were to be influenced by the collapse of a so-called Scioto Company whose
Northwest Territory holdings were envisioned as appealing to French Noblemen who stood to lose much
in the ultimate outcome of the French Revolution. One of those who had left a tumultuous France for the
new United States of America was Madame Bacler de Leval whom Mr. Duer tried to interest in the Maine
lands as the site of her envisioned French asylum. But Mr. Duer went bankrupt; no French nobility
arrived; Madame de Leval married and moved to New York.
The apparent rescuer of the Maine adventure was the prominent, very wealthy Philadelphia citizen, Mr.
William Bingham, who, through his agent, negotiated the purchase of Mr. Duer's claims and part of those
of Mr. Knox. With his national and international reputation as a successful business man and his
important connections with such European banking houses as Barings of London and Hopes of
Amsterdam, he set out in 1793 to attract buyers/settlers to these two tracts of Maine wilderness
bordered by the Kennebec River and the earlier-settled coastal areas. Highlighted in the promotions
were the regions great natural resources. Mr. Baring's appeals to wealthy Europeans, through both
letters and the personal efforts of his agent, Mr. William Jackson, to invest in the land were about as
fruitful as those earlier attempts of Messrs. Duer and Knox.
It was then that Mr. Bingham decided to appoint an on-site agent to protect his holdings from timber
thieves, to survey the territories, and to find buyers for parcels of land. Populating this earlier purchased
property was a condition attached to his acquiring the land from Massachusetts.
In 1795, General David Cobb of Taunton, Massachusetts, was so employed. He was a man with a
reputation as a doctor, an army officer, a patriot in the Revolutionary War who fought in various battles
and was an aide to General George Washington, a judge, a representative to the Massachusetts
General Court, a Speaker of the House, and a representative from Massachusetts to the Third US
Congress. Having lost a 1795 contest for re-election, he was receptive to Mr. Bingham's offer to serve as
his agent in Maine.
Meanwhile, Mr. Bingham had acquired additional seacoast property in Gouldsborough, Trenton,
Ellsworth, and Mt Desert. Consequently, General Cobb had oversight of over 2,000,000 acres, "most of
http://www.woodlawnmuseum.org/historyfull.html
5/24/2014
inc woodiawil vuseum, an Extended History
Page L of /
it unsurveyed, unexplored, and uninhabited." (Anonymous, The Black Mansion: Historical Introduction
(p. 10). He began at once "the puffing of Maine" (lbid., p. 11) in local Boston papers. The generous
incentives offered those who would settle in this vast, resource-rich wilderness simply did not yield the
desired results. Upon retrospect, it was General Cobb's vision of the agricultural potential of these
woodlands that may have doomed all his efforts to but the most modest of success. In fact, he boasted
of his focus on farmers "of the first breed of the Old Colony-the descendents [sic] of Ancestry from the
West of England and untainted with disorganized blood either Savage or Civil, and whose industry will
make a wilderness to blossom like the Rose and the flinty surface of the Rocks to rejoice with
fertility." (lbid., p. 11)
Such optimism is all the more remarkable when seen in the context of all the problems he was to
encounter, such as those created by the pre-1784 settlers who appropriated to themselves a right to
lands not owned and the conditions created by nature. Following his June 8, 1795 arrival in
Gouldsborough, he wrote to Mr. Bingham about "people almost blind by the bites of flies and musketoes
[sic]." He went on to project, that Mr. Bingham could "have no conception of the hosts of these devils
that infest the thick forest in summer months." (lbid., p. 13)
Efforts to sell land to the extant settlers were crippled by their poverty. So, to advance his vision of these
Maine lands, appeals were made to "wealthier farmers" of more settled sections of the nation. General
Cobb viewed the unrestrained cutting of forests the reason for the devaluation of the soil that he,
possibly without close investigation, described as the "finest in the world." He passionately urged respect
for property and the growth of agriculture. Consequently, he spared no effort to reign in the lumber trade
to protect Mr. Bingham's investments.
For Mr. Bingham, the Maine purchase represented enormous expense and little return, a situation that
was to strain the Bingham-Cobb relationship. He continued to seek European buyers through the efforts
of Mr. William Jackson. In November of 1795, General Cobb was called to Philadelphia, in anticipation of
the arrival of the son of Sir Francis Baring, Alexander, who was coming to America on behalf of a group
of European bankers, particularly Barings of London and Hopes of Amsterdam, now interested in
purchasing land. The deal, completed in February of 1796, gave Mr. Baring one-half interest in the
"Penobscot million" and one-half interest in a third tract of acquired property north of this million-acre
expanse. Sir Baring, to become Lord Ashburton, was himself to play a role in both the economic and
political history of Maine in general and Down East Maine in particular, Along with Daniel Webster, he
negotiated the treaty that resolved the disputes over Maine's northwest boundary.
But history continued to follow a bumpy course after 1796. The strain on Mr. Bingham's resources from
the Maine investments (he had spent $60,000 from 1796-1801 alone) and other developments, both
personal and financial, caused him to seek a way out of the deal-but not at any cost. He died in 1804.
Nor was General Cobb happy. The ongoing trouble with timber thieves, the tensions that had developed
between him and Mr. Bingham over finances and general expectations, the lack of any concrete
achievements-these factors took their toll. He did not know how to proceed after 1804, although the
trustees of Mr. Bingham's estate had assured him of support. By the time that estate was settled, there
were the consequences of the War of 1812 with its embargo, especially hard on eastern Maine, thereby
making more difficult an economy in trouble.
To the very end, General Cobb envisioned Maine's success primarily in terms of its agricultural potential.
In 1822, the General returned to Taunton, Massachusetts where he died in 1830.
Obviously, such conditions could never have permitted the construction of Woodlawn. That another
vision of Maine would prevail is explained by the role of Colonel John Black who looked beyond the trees
to see the forests as Maine's greatest financial resource. It is Sir Francis Baring or Lord Ashburton who
is responsible for bringing John Black to Maine and thereby for measurably shaping its economic history.
An Englishman born in 1781 in London, John Black was hired by Sir Francis to serve as a clerk to
General Cobb and to Sir Francis' agent, Mr. John Richards. He arrived in Gouldsborough in 1799. His
exceptional talents resulted in his assuming an ever-increasing role in the affairs of the Bingham-Baring
Maine partnership. In 1802, he married General Cobb's daughter, Mary. When the Ellsworth sub-agent,
Mr. Donald Ross, died in 1805, Mr. Black was eventually appointed his successor and moved to
http://www.woodlawnmuseum.org/historyfull.html
5/24/2014
ne woodlawn Museum, an Extended History
Page 3 of /
Ellsworth in 1810 where he would live and transform Mr. Bingham's original investment into a high-yield
performer. Mr. Black took part in the War of 1812 and was broadly recognized for his patriotism, his
friendly personality, his honest ways, and his exceptional business abilities.
As his father-in-law, General Cobb, was edged out of the picture, Col. John Black was moving to its
center. He was eventually appointed general agent of all the Bingham estate's Maine properties. It is
important to note that his focus was not on agriculture but on lumber trade, which was to grow
exponentially in the 1830's, 40's, and 50's. The contrast between the Cobb's early home in
Gouldsborough and the Black Mansion in Ellsworth can be viewed as a critique of the different visions
for the area held by these two men. Woodlawn Museum (The Black House) in Ellsworth captures the
essence of the history of post-Revolutionary War and mid-Nineteenth Century Maine. Rebecca Robbins,
in her monograph, "Colonel John Black of Ellsworth," published in 1978, claims, "Black can indeed be
credited with helping launch Maine's lumbering industry, for he quickly saw that timber was the State's
prime resource."
Col. Black's duties as Mr. Bingham's agent, his success in the lumber business which made him not only
very wealthy but provided the heirs of Mr. Bingham resources undoubtedly beyond his fondest dreams,
and his success as a retailer brought him into contact with many people. His voluminous papers, located
at Woodlawn, are estimated to contain materials relating to over 3200 individuals.
He built Woodlawn between 1824 and 1828 and furnished it with items dated as early as 1650. There he
and his wife, Mary Cobb, raised a family. After his death in 1856, his second wife and widow remained in
residence at Woodlawn until her death in 1874. Son George, who inherited his father's business
enterprises and Woodlawn, left Ellsworth for Boston in the 1860's, returning but occasionally. In 1865, he
ended his agency of the Bingham lands and liquidated in 1870 the family's businesses. His son, also
named George, inherited Woodlawn in 1880 and spent summers in Ellsworth until his death in 1928. His
will bequeaths Woodlawn to the Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations "as a public park: the
house and grounds and wood roads to be kept as they now are the main house to be
always
kept
in
order and open to visitors under reasonable regulations but not to be occupied."
And so stands, today, in Ellsworth a magnificent estate, essentially unaltered, on 180 wooded acres with
magnificent trails. The red brick house, of the Federal period, with features and contents truly
remarkable, is a treasure. To appreciate fully Woodlawn's significance, one should view it as an
embodiment of national and international developments that would help give shape to America-
particularly the Down East section of the Pine Tree State.
The Black House connects a difficult, challenging past and the present. It serves as a testimony to the
vision and abilities of a man who saw the heart of the Maine economy in the 19th century to be in those
very trees that others viewed as a barrier to agricultural development of the land. That Col. Black named
his residence Woodlawn appropriately summarizes the story.
The governance of the Black House is essentially determined by the will of George Nixon Black and by
the purposes and bylaws of the Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations. A brief examination of
each of these instruments is instructive.
The will of George Nixon Black specifies that the Black Estate, "called Woodlawn, including the land,
buildings, furniture, and pictures therein," was to be bequeathed to the City of Ellsworth, Maine
as a public park; the house and grounds and wood roads to be kept as they now are, a caretaker to be
employed, who shall be permitted to occupy the kitchen and adjoining rooms in the "L" of the house only;
the main house to be always kept in order and open to visitors under reasonable regulations, but not to
be occupied.
The will further states that Mr. Black was "greatly interested in not having the trees cut for any purpose
whatever." Also given to the City of Ellsworth were
the portraits of General David Cobb, my great grandfather, and the portraits of my grandfather and
grandmother Black, my father and mother, my sisters and myself, and all furniture which belonged to
General Cobb, now in Boston, Manchester or Ellsworth houses, and direct that they be marked as such
http://www.woodlawnmuseum.org/historyfull.html
5/24/2014
ne woodlawn Museum, an Extended History
Page 4 of 7
respectively and kept as a memorial at said Woodlawn. I also give to the said City of Ellsworth the sum
of Fifty Thousand Dollars, to be safely invested; the income of said Fund to be used forever in keeping
the house, land, roads and property in order and repair, and to pay for a caretaker.
In a second codicil to this will, dated August 3,1911, Mr. Black directed that the
Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations, a corporation organized under Chapter fifty-five of the
Revised Statutes of 1883 of the State of Maine, its organization having been ratified by chapter three
hundred sixty-nine of the private and special laws of 1903 of the legislature of said State of Maine rather
than the City of Ellsworth be the recipient of the estate. He regarded the Hancock County Trustees of
Public Reservations to be more experienced than was Ellsworth in administration, "more suitable for the
care of such a trust."
The Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations itself has a fascinating history. Its creation is in
large measure the result of a vision or concern of Charles W. Eliot, President of Harvard from 1869 to
1909, who had been for years a summer resident of Northeast Harbor. In 1901 he suggested to
neighbors and friends the formation of an organization to conserve and maintain the natural beauties of
Mt. Desert.
The impetus for this suggestion was the increase in private ownership of vast areas of the Island, a trend
President Eliot saw as resulting in depriving the public of access to "many beautiful hills, points and
beaches." (The Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations: An Historical Sketch and a record of
the Holdings of the Trustees, 1939 (p. 7). To avoid this, he envisioned an organization "to secure and
maintain reservations for public use." (lbid., p. 7)
President Eliot was following a precedent established by his son, Charles, who created an organization
whose members were substantial Massachusetts citizens to be known as the Trustees of Public
Reservations who "would be empowered to acquire parcels of real estate possessing natural beauty or
historical interest and to hold them for public use and enjoyment." (Ibid., pp. 7-8)
The Maine counterpart to this Massachusetts entity was to have a similar purpose, namely, "to acquire,
hold, and maintain and improve for free public use lands in Hancock County which by reason of scenic
beauty, historical interest, sanitary advantage or for other reasons may be available for the purpose.
(Ibid., p. 8) The meeting called by President Eliot for considering this proposal was held September 12,
1901. Thus was born the organization to be known as the Hancock County Trustees of Public
Reservations. Its incorporation was confirmed by the Maine legislature in 1903.
Eight men incorporated this entity. It was headquartered in Bar Harbor and claimed 44 members in its
first year. Its original intent, as a volunteer organization, was simply "to preserve for public enjoyment the
scenic and historic sites of Mount Desert." (lbid., p. 7)
The organization received from wealthy individuals thousands of acres, all tax exempt. In 1913, there
was an unsuccessful Maine legislature attempt to deny the HCTPR its tax exemption-an effort initiated in
response to the growing concern of the Island residents about the large tracts of land which were being
removed from the tax rolls. However, the issue was sufficiently weighty to cause the Trustees to look for
alternative ways to accomplish their purposes. So, in 1914, Mr. George B. Dorr, First Vice President of
the corporation, went to Washington to have the Trustees' holdings consolidated in a "national
monument or a park." (Ibid., p. 12)
On July 8, 1916, President Wilson signed the executive order "establishing [sic] the Sieur de Monts
National Monument." (Ibid., p. 13) Three years later, Congress passed an act establishing Lafayette
National Park. In 1929, President Coolidge approved a bill changing the name to Acadia National Park
"and authorized the inclusion in the Park holdings of lands beyond the boundaries of the Park." (lbid., p.
12)
The record noted that in 1929 the Trustees received under the will of George Nixon Black of Boston the
"noble old Black Mansion (Woodlawn) at Ellsworth."
The bequest included the house with its unique collection of old time furnishings and pictures, the
http://www.woodlawnmuseum.org/historyfull.html
5/24/2014
the Woodlawn Museum, an Extended History
Page 5 of 7
carriage house and its ancient vehicles, the well-kept gardens and grounds, the remarkable woodlands
accessible by the roads built by Colonel Black more than a century ago, and a modest fund for
insurance, repairs, and upkeep. The Estate is administered by a special committee of the Trustees of
which Mr. Richard W. Hale has been the efficient chairman ever since the trust was accepted. (lbid., p.
13)
The vast previous holdings of the Trustees had, for all practical purposes, passed on to the Federal
Government for care and maintenance, leaving "the Black Estate [as] the largest and most important unit
under the care of the Trustees." (Ibid., p. 13)
Today, Woodlawn is legally owned by the Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations. Its purpose
is defined by the articles of incorporation of this organization; its responsibilities are additionally
prescribed by the will of George Nixon Black.
The governing body of the Corporation is identified as the Board of Trustees, to be composed of the
elected officers (President, Vice-President, Secretary, and Treasurer) and individuals duly elected by the
Nominating Committee. The Board of Trustees may have up to 21 members but no fewer than 11. The
Bylaws (included in the appendix of this handbook) state that the Board of Trustees shall have general
management and control of the business, property and work of the Corporation" and that the Board
"may, by general resolution, delegate to committees of their own number, to the executive director or to
officers of the Corporation such powers as it sees fit and shall specify the manner and frequency with
which they shall report to the board." (Article III, Section 1).
WOODLAWN'S NATIONAL SIGNIFICANCE
Located in Ellsworth, ME, Woodlawn is a late Federal-style brick house built between 1824 and 1827
based on Plate 54, "Plan and elevation for a house which is intended for a country situation," in Asher
Benjamin's American Builder's Companion. Advanced for its time, the house remains a significant
example of early 19th century domestic architecture in Maine. The house was occupied for 100 years by
three generations of the Black family. The furnishings of the house are all original, allowing present day
scholars to study one of New England's most comprehensive family collections still in tact. Woodlawn is
also the repository for the extensive Black family archives which help illustrate the economic and political
development of Maine, and the house stands as a reminder of the nascent historic preservation
movement of the early twentieth century that resulted in the saving of important historic sites and the
founding of Acadia National Park.
The property was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 1969 as a site of local significance.
However, the national significance of this property is multifaceted and needs to be recognized for the
many ways that the individuals associated with it influenced the economic growth and political definition
of our nation in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Four of the broad National Landmark
themes can be used to assess Woodlawn when considering its significance in the national context. The
shaping of the political landscape, the development of the American economy, the transforming of the
environment, and the changing role of the United States in the World community are all understood
better at a national level when examined through the lens of Woodlawn. A brief history of the individuals
associated with Woodlawn is a good beginning for the investigation of these four themes.
In 1793, William Bingham of Philadelphia speculated in the rapid settlement of the Maine frontier by
purchasing two million acres of land that became known as the Kennebec Purchase and the Penobscot
Purchase. He hired General David Cobb, once a top-ranking aide to General George Washington during
the Revolutionary War, to act as his land agent for the Penobscot Tract. The sale of land did not proceed
as hoped and soon Mr. Bingham found himself overextended financially. He sold half of his interest in
the land to the Baring and Hope banking companies of London. John Black, a nineteen-year-old clerk in
the Baring Bank, was sent to America to assist General Cobb in the administration of the land. Over
time, this assignment proved advantageous to all involved. From this business relationship William
Bingham found financial security, Alexander Baring began a long personal, political, and successful
business association with America, and John Black found a new home and his life's work.
While David Cobb served as the first Land Agent in Gouldsboro, Maine, it was not long before John
Black was overseeing the business. Black soon became a naturalized citizen, married General Cobb's
daughter, and succeeded his father-in-law as Penobscot Agent, eventually taking over the administration
http://www.woodlawnmuseum.org/historyfull.html
5/24/2014
The Woodlawn Museum, an Extended History
Page 6 of 7
of both the Kennebec and the Penobscot Tracts. He has been cited by Richard Wood, in his book A
History of Lumbering in Maine 1820-1861, as the most active of all the land proprietors in the District of
Maine (then part of Massachusetts) and the agent responsible for abandoning the misguided plan to
promote the agricultural development of Maine lands, and redirecting it to the exploitation of the natural
timber resources. Thus, Black promoted the development of the lumbering industry that still fuels
Maine's economy today.
Many individuals profited from John Black's vision for the land, but few attained the success that Black
himself did. He manufactured lumber, exported his own, and that of others, on ships he owned and then
imported goods through businesses he set up for his sons to run. At one time, Black and his sons were
shipping lumber to Europe, the Caribbean, points along the east coast, and even to the Pacific coast. As
his success as agent for the Bingham lands grew so did his personal wealth. When he died in 1856, an
article in the Ellsworth American boasted that he left" probably the largest estate ever left by any
person in the state east of Portland."
During his lifetime, Black was associated with many of the personalities who helped shape the early
nation. Although he never held state or national office himself, Black widely influenced the politics and
commerce of Maine as it entered Statehood in 1820, and up until his death in 1856. At various times
John held the position of town clerk, Justice of the Peace, and Colonel in the Massachusetts Militia. He
often lobbied in the State government for issues that would benefit the economy and political well-being
of Maine.
Associated with Woodlawn is the significant archival collection that is housed there. All of the business
records of Colonel Black and his sons exist as do significant personal letters, schooner records, and
business letters that link Colonel Black with over 3,200 individuals or businesses in Maine and beyond.
Other documents in the archives include maps, receipts for purchases made for Woodlawn when it was
built as well as later on, and letters between other members of the Black family. Although the Colonel's
grandson, George Nixon Black Jr., bequeathed numerous other family papers relating to General David
Cobb to the Colonial Society of Massachusetts in 1928, some primary documentation pertaining to
General Cobb remains at Woodlawn. This collection of nineteenth century documents is vital to an
understanding of the lumbering industry in down east Maine from both an economic and a political point
of view.
One particularly important part of the Black archives is a set of correspondence between John Black and
his English employer, Alexander Baring (more widely known as Lord Ashburton). The correspondence
occurs at the time Daniel Webster and Lord Ashburton were negotiating the U.S.-Canadian border in
1842. During the period of negotiations, Colonel Black traveled to Washington, D.C. to meet with Lord
Ashburton. Few Englishmen had a greater affection for and understanding of Maine than did Lord
Ashburton and John Black. It is evident that Ashburton held John Black's opinions in high esteem and
that Black may have influenced the course of the boundary dispute talks.
By honesty, astute observation, and a broad national and international sensibility John Black rose from
the position of clerk to become one of the wealthiest men in Maine. But the significance of Woodlawn
and those associated with it is not limited to John Black alone. His son and grandson maintained and
augmented the family fortune and influence. Both George Nixon Black and George Nixon Black Jr.
conducted their business from Boston. While there is still much to be learned about the social position of
the Blacks, it parallels that of many families who attained great wealth during the industrial revolution.
George Jr. was influenced by his peers in Boston and participated in many of the interests common to
the upper class at the close of the nineteenth century. He built the famous shingle style summer cottage
"Kragside" in Manchester Massachusetts and collected fine European and American art and furniture.
His legacy reflects his interest in preserving the colonial American heritage, and honoring the men who
built this nation. George was a member of the Colonial Society of Massachusetts. At his death he
bequeathed large sums of money and his collections to cultural institutions, the most significant being
the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. It was he who left Woodlawn to the Hancock County Trustees of Public
Reservations to be kept as a public park in perpetuity.
The influence that John Black and his family had on the development of Maine is still affecting the State
today. When John Black arrived in the District of Maine, it was generally viewed as the last frontier left in
New England. His role as land agent for William Bingham and the Baring Bank of London put him in a
http://www.woodlawnmuseum.org/historyfull.html
5/24/2014
The Woodlawn Museum, an Extended History
Page 7 of 7
position to assess the potential of this land. Seeing the success of smaller lumbering operations, he
quickly ascertained that the future of Maine lay its woods, bringing him great personal wealth. Lumbering
became the economic backbone of Maine and marks the first and still continuing effort to harvest
America's vast natural resources.
For two generations the Blacks profited from the land. By the third generation, it is significant to find
George Nixon Black Jr. transferring Woodlawn and its surrounding 180-acres to the Hancock County
Trustees of Public Reservation, an organization that was founded to preserve forests and scenic lands in
the area. This group donated much of the land that is now Acadia National Park to the federal
government, making it the largest gift of land to the government east of the Mississippi and the only
private group to found a national park. Thus, the principle member of the third generation of the Black
family sought to maintain his grandfather's legacy through the twentieth century practices of land
conservation and historic preservation, shifting the family's interests from commerce to land
conservation.
www.woodlawnmuseum.com ©2008 Woodlawn Museum
http://www.woodlawnmuseum.org/historyfull.html
5/24/2014
WOODLAWN
M u S E u M
The Black House
MAINE'S
PREMIER HISTORIO ESTATE
Summer 2006
A Property of the Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations
vol. 3 no. 3
Curious George: Woodlawn's Enigmatic Benefactor
by Jane Goodrich
On the frosty morning of November 1, 1928, the
citizens of Hancock County awoke to find they had been
given a marvelous gift. A few days earlier, on October
29, George Nixon Black, Jr. had died in his Beacon Street
home in Boston of the effects of arteriosclerosis. 1 He was 86
years old. In a will in which Mr. Black had painted a dozen
institutions with a very charitable brush, his hometown had
not been forgotten. Woodlawn now belonged to everyone.
It was an astonishing final act, but one which had been
foreshadowed. Thirty years earlier, in 1897, Mr. Black
had gifted Ellsworth with a new library remodeled from
the handsome Tisdale house, another jewel in the city's
architectural crown.
Although George Nixon Black, Jr. had lived in Boston
for nearly 70 years he always cherished his Maine roots.
Woodlawn, along with its furnishings and history, was
probably his most valued possession. He relished his summer
visits to Ellsworth where he indulged in his horses, dogs,
parties and antiquing trips. When needed, he remodeled
and decorated Woodlawn with great care, judiciously
adding objects that reflected his colonial revival tastes but
wisely leaving the furnishings chosen for the house by his
grandparents, John and Mary Black, in place. He enjoyed
telling the stories of his great-grandfather General David
Cobb's role in the Revolutionary War, and especially prized
General Cobb's close connection to George Washington.
fings Arim Bluck
That he conceived of Woodlawn as a museum and public
park is no surprise, as he desired to keep his family history
Photo of George Nixon Black, Jr., circa 1864, from
alive.
Woodlawn collections.
Yet, due either to humility or design, his own history is
strikingly absent. Woodlawn contains thousands of letters,
Continued on page 3...
Curious George (continued from page 1)
business records, deeds and travel journals, but fewer than
a dozen were penned by George, Jr. A small collection of
historic photographs exists, but there are more prints and
paintings representing George Washington in the Woodlawn
collection than there are pictures of the George who
bequeathed it. In fact, George, Jr. has SO successfully slipped
behind the curtain of his own ancestry that today few people
know he was never called George at all. To distinguish him
from his father he was always called Nixon.
Nixon was born July 11, 1842 in Ellsworth. He was
the second child and the only son of George Nixon Black,
Sr. and his wife, Mary Peters Black. He was educated by
private tutors, often along with his sisters, Marianne and
Agnes Black. When he was eleven he took dancing lessons
and he may have had some painting and drawing lessons as
well. In 1860, when he was 18 years old, he moved with
his family to Pemberton Square on Beacon Hill in Boston.
It must have been an amazing change for a young man of
artistic sensibilities after growing up in small-town Maine.
At the time, Boston was the fifth largest city in the United
States with a population just under 180,000. 4
Miniature portrait of George Nixon Black, Jr., painted by
Boston was also undergoing great physical change.
Laura Coombs Hills. Woodlawn Museum collections.
The area north and west of Beacon Hill where the family
lived is today tree-lined and quaint, but was, in 1860, one
that a man take a military part in the war but many students
huge construction site. The massive work project of filling
from both the North and the South left Harvard to join their
the Back Bay began in 1858 just west of the present Boston
respective forces. The nation was in a tumult. Financial
Public Garden. In those years 35 train cars, loaded with
markets were in a panic. Nothing would ever be the same.
gravel were making the 9-mile run from a quarry in West
It took a steady hand and an astute eye to negotiate
Needham, every hour, twenty-four hours a day, six days a
a real estate business through these years of exaggerated
week.
5 This filling continued (although at a slower pace)
growth and crisis, but fortunately George Nixon Black, Sr.
for the next 36 years, finally finishing in 1894 in the Fens
possessed both. Determined and painfully hard working,
near the present Boston Museum of Fine Arts. Houses
the elder Black had grown the wealth left to him by his
and shops were built on this "new land" almost as quickly
own father's businesses to a size never dreamed of by the
as it was leveled and graded, and a great migration of the
first generation. Following Nixon's failure to matriculate
population of Boston was underway. Derided at the time
at Harvard, and after allowing his son a year of travel in
by Henry James "as a tract pompous and prosaic", it was in
Europe, George, Sr. brought Nixon into the family business.
the Back Bay that Nixon's generation of men "established
The two men worked together for the next 14 years building
Boston as one of the centers of world culture in the arts and
a commercial real estate empire.
sciences. ,6
It is difficult to imagine how a young man interested
It was also a frightening time. Nixon entered Harvard
in art, history and horses took to the drudgery of real estate
College in the fall of 1860 but he had trouble there and
work. We know very little of Nixon's life during these
attended for less than a year. The Civil War had broken out
years, but it seems that he accepted his duty and did his best
and although Nixon did not enlist, many students dropped
to work well at it. Small glimpses of the man he was to
out at this time and classes were half-empty with their
become are evidenced in two contemporary letters. In one,
departure. The culture of the time by no means insisted
Nixon's interest in, and expertise on the opera are spoken
3
of. In later years he was a constant box holder at the Boston
New Jerusalem" and depicting John's Biblical vision on
Opera. In the other, Nixon's father writes, "Nixon and
Patmos, the window was installed in the west wall of the
Agnes are visiting the museum this afternoon."
North Transept during the winter of 1883-1884. It was the
The Boston Museum of Fine Arts became one of Nixon's
first memorial window commissioned from master artist
lifetime passions. At the time of his death, the MFA was his
John LaFarge who was also responsible for the painted
major beneficiary. Incorporated in 1870, the Museum was
decoration inside the church. In creating the window, LaFarge
first housed on the top floor of the Boston Athenaeum, very
employed every innovative technique in his repertoire using
close to the Black's home at 81 Mt. Vernon Street. The
six different types of glass and extensive jewel work. The
1870's marked the infancy of the years in which America
amazing window, still visible at Trinity today, was the first
was emerging from its long dependence on European
and finest artwork Nixon ever commissioned.
culture. A new nationalism was overtaking the country to
The early 1880's also gave rise to thoughts about
culminate in the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia.
housing for Nixon and his family. After 22 years of living
In Boston, the apex of this new expression was to be found
at Mt Vernon Street they moved to 57 Beacon Street early
at Art Square. Built on land created by the filling of Back
in 1883. It was at this address that Nixon, his mother and
Bay in the mid 1860's, Art Square (today's Copley Square)
younger sister all lived for the remainder of their lives. The
was anchored by the opening of the new Museum of Fine
Beacon Street house was one of a pair of bowfront row
Arts in July 1876. The following February Trinity Church
houses designed by Ephraim Marsh in 1819. Both survive
was dedicated. In 1896 the square was finished with the
today, although #57 has now been separated into several
addition of the masterpiece Boston Public Library building,
living units.
creating one of the most architecturally distinguished public
Most Bostonians of the upper classes did not spend
squares in America, both then and now.
summers in the city. No record exists of where the Black
Whether Nixon and his family supported the MFA in
family may have traveled before the death of George, Sr.,
these early years is not known. What can be suspected is
but soon after Nixon began thinking of a summer home
that a man of Nixon's interests could not have helped but
by the sea. In this regard, he turned to his old college
be excited and moved by these wonderful cultural changes
classmate and friend, Robert Swain Peabody. Peabody,
happening in Boston in the mid 1870's. It would have to
an accomplished architect in his own firm of Peabody and
wait until he was the head of his own household to see what
Stearns was, in 1883, working at the height of his youthful
he would do on his own.
creative powers.
In October 1880, George Nixon Black, Sr. died, -
By January of 1884, local newspapers reported that the
probably at Woodlawn- while on a trip to Ellsworth. More
framed roof of George Nixon Black, Jr's Kragsyde was
disturbing perhaps for Nixon, was the death of his sister,
Marianne Black, the following year. Tradition indicates
that Marianne was in poor health due to a weak heart for
much of her life, but the sudden death of the unmarried 42
year-old woman following so closely the death of her father
left the remainder of the family shocked and shaken. Thrust
suddenly into the role of being "the man of the family"
seems to have been for Nixon a form of liberation. Finally
free to make his own decisions, and to exert his own tastes,
he wasted no time in doing
The deaths of his father and elder sister provided an
opportunity for Nixon to commission an artwork and honor
his family at the same time. What better memorial than a
stained glass window to be placed in the new Trinity Church
at Art Square? The resulting window is one of the great
George Nixon Black, Jr. Manchester-by-the-Sea estate,
stained glass masterpieces of Trinity Church. Named "The
Kragsyde. From the author's private collection.
4
showing above Smith's Point in Manchester-by-the-Sea,
Massachusetts."
The diaries of Robert Peabody indicate
visits to the building site with Nixon in February and July
of 1884.
10 Although neither man could have known it at
the time, Kragsyde not only became Peabody and Stearns'
one great masterpiece, it also became the masterpiece and
icon of the entire shingle style of architecture. Rambling,
haunting and evocative, the beautiful house set high on a
dramatic headland was famous in its day and was published
several times both in Europe and America. Nixon and his
family occupied the house every summer from May until
October to the end of their lives. Sadly, the house did not
share the same fate as Woodlawn and was torn down in
1929, the year after Nixon died.
The choice of the shingle style was a natural one
for Nixon. The opposite of the showy marble and stone
palaces of Newport, Rhode Island which aped European
styles, the shingle style, appealed to the quieter Bostonian
taste. Broad open porches, furnished with simple rocking
chairs and rows of uneven shingles greying in the salt air,
reminded even these millionaire cottagers of their colonial
roots. Containing many elements of the later colonial
revival style, this engaging type of building gave a quiet
Several prominent Manchester residents pose as pilgrims
nod to Yankee Puritan virtues, and silent approval to the
in 1895. Nixon is standing second from right behind young
age and endurance of Boston money. Raw, unmanicured
boy. Courtesy of the Manchester Historical Society.
landscapes and tumbling masses of flowers provided the
backdrop against the very coast where the ancestors of these
and soldiers from the Colonial wars. Parades, tea parties,
cottagers arrived in America. At Kragsyde, there also stood
picnics, bell and gun salutes ensued as well as a reenactment
a picturesque carriage house and a large greenhouse where
of the famous (and historically dubious) landing. 11
In
Nixon engaged in his hobby of growing and exhibiting
a photograph of the day we find Nixon, grinning, in full
specimen plants, flowers, and vegetables.
Puritan regalia standing as a member of Winthrop's party on
By 1895 when Nixon was 53 years old he was probably
the float at the Manchester Yacht Club.
at the fullest and happiest point of his life. Deeply influenced
It was also in 1895 that Nixon again expressed his
by the colonial revival and his own family history he was
interest in both the visual arts and the colonial revival.
at this time actively engaged in collecting furniture, china,
Portrait miniatures painted on ivory were coming back into
silver and paintings. Much of this collection was gifted to
vogue after being out of fashion for half a century. In Boston,
the Museum of Fine Arts at his death. It was probably about
the artist Laura Coombs Hills led the revival of miniature
this time when he began decorating the "colonial" middle
painting. Already acclaimed for her watercolor and pastel
kitchen at Woodlawn and he was certainly in the planning
paintings of flowers, Miss Hills visited England in the early
stages of the remodeling of the Ellsworth library.
1890's and saw her first miniatures there. She brought home
On July 18, 1895, Manchester-by-the Sea celebrated
some of these ivories and began to teach herself the art of
the 250th anniversary of the landing of John Winthrop and
painting on them. By 1897 she was elected to the Society
his party aboard the Arbella. In what was a colonial revival
of American Artists as its first miniature painter. 12 Her style
extravaganza, citizens of the town dressed in costume as John
was fresh and painterly and avidly sought by collectors. She
Winthrop and his party, Chief Masconomo and his Indian
greeters, continentals, local lady spinners with their wheels,
Continued on page 10.
5
Curious George (continued from page 5)
kept a detailed diary of her sitters and it is no surprise that
a Harvard education and then later endowed libraries. A
Nixon was one of her first, as well as one of the few men she
curious blend of humility and fierceness, he had both the
painted (see image on page 3). Nixon's mother also sat for
courage to insist upon his unconventional life and the
her own miniature, but it is Nixon's that is the most striking.
humility to commemorate it in the simplest manner possible
Hearty, happy and with vivid blue eyes and a stylish fur coat
on his tiny marble headstone at Mt. Auburn Cemetery in
he smiles out at us from the small oval of ivory as one of
Cambridge, Massachusetts.
the finest male miniature subjects Hills ever painted. This
Yet, it was as a patron that Nixon was his most singular.
commission tells more than the story of Nixon's love for
Possessed of the confidence and discrimination to recognize
the colonial revival. It speaks also of his support for all
talent, and yet restrained enough not to meddle with it, he
artists, male or female. In fact, of the two portraits Nixon is
was responsible for breathing life into several enduring
known to have commissioned of himself, both were made
pieces of art. His greatest genius may well have been the
by female artists.
ability to coax not only good work from his artist friends,
On November 11, 1904 events occurred which led to
but their best work.
Nixon's last great gift to the artistic and cultural community
in his lifetime. On this day a disastrous fire swept through
1
Death certificate October 29, 1928 Massachusetts State
Archives
the Harcourt Building of artists' studios, located just west
2
Will- George Nixon Black, Jr. Suffolk County Courthouse,
of Art Square. Several artists barely escaped with their
Boston, Massachusetts
lives and many others, including such notables as William
3
Manchester Breeze, July 21, 1906
M. Paxton and Joseph DeCamp, had their life's work
4
When in Boston, A Time Line & Almanac, Jim Vrabel,
destroyed. Almost immediately, a group of prominent
Bostonian Society 2004
5
When in Boston, A Time Line & Almanac, Jim Vrabel,
artists approached a group of prominent businessmen and
Bostonian Society, 2004
the Fenway Studios Trust was born. Working quickly,
6
Quoted from Lewis Mumford
architects engineered a studio building that the artists had
7
Woodlawn Museum Archives.
designed, and subscriptions were solicited to raise funds for
8
Facts About Trinity Stained Glass, Trinity Church, 2004.
the new structure. In just three months two trustees and
9
Cape Ann Advertiser, January 18, 1884
10 Diaries of Robert Swain Peabody, Boston Architectural
fourteen subscribers had raised the money and donated
Center, Boston, Massachusetts
the land. Of course, Nixon signed on as a subscriber at
11 Official Programme Peabody Essex Phillips Library, Salem,
the onset. Amazingly, the new building was finished and
Massachusetts
occupied within a year of the Harcourt fire. The artist
12 Laura Coombs Hills, A Retrospective- Historical Society of
occupants who used the building were among America's
Old Newbury, 1996
13 Fenway Studios, The Evolution of an Artist's Community in
most famous, and teachers from the Museum School used
Boston, Nancy Allyn Jarzombeck, 1998
the studios for classes. Fenway Studios remain today as
they were intended, fully occupied by a new generation of
artists plying their trade.
13
In the end, biography always falls short. The subject,
aided by the silt of time still manages to elude our grasp.
Nixon remains a delightful enigma. In 1842 when he
was born, the northern border of the state of Maine had
barely been settled with New Brunswick. (It would take a
GEORGE
remarkable youth to develop a love of art while growing up
NIXON
in a place where he barely saw it, and a strong swimmer to
get from the icy, frontier waters of the Downeast coast to the
BLACK
important artistic and intellectual currents of his time
So too, his powers of observation and self-interrogation
must have been notable. He was after all, a man who declined
10
beth F. Call, Mr. & Mrs.
REBECCA ROBBINS
1. Johnson, Mr. Theodore
Mrs. Valerie Nichols, Mrs.
J. Young, Jr. Scarborough:
Colonel John Black of Ellsworth
tland: Mrs. Anne J. Phillips
(1781-1856)
Malcolin Yarmouth; Mr.
Morgan, Jr.
Colonel John Black, agent for the estate of William
ank: Mrs. Helen E. Craig
Bingham, was one of early Maine's most ambitious and
Dudley C. Lunt NEW
hard-working businessmen. A meticulous record keeper,
yd T. Smith NEW YORK
his papers provide a detailed picture of his widely-ranging
Marchon PENNSYLVANIA
activities. Though largely consisting of business records,
Thompson, Sr. RHODE
the Black Papers, from the family mansion, "Woodlawn",
Paoli VIRGINIA Arlington:
at Ellsworth, contain some personal material as well. These
letters, bills, receipts and memos allow one to get a more
intimate glimpse at this extraordinary man. As Colonel
bers
Black's business dealings have been dealt with at length
; E. Lord
elsewhere, it is the private aspect of Mr. Black's life which
irginia
will be focused on here.
T. Pierce
First, however, it will be helpful to provide some back-
W York
ground information on the so-called "Bingham Lands"
in Maine.2 In 1793, William Bingham, a prominent
Philadelphia businessman, purchased two large tracts
in Maine, of approximately one million acres each.
These became known as the Kennebec Purchase, en-
compassing a large part of what is now Somerset
). 2)
County, often referred to as the "Million Acres"; and the
87, para 3, line 13, Zetas read
Penobscot Purchase, located in Washington and Hancock
d Asher; p. 87, para 3, line 16,
counties. In 1796, Bingham, faced with financial diffi-
read after; p. 90, para 4, line 1,
culties, succeeded in selling a half-interest in his lands to
line 5, verticle read vertical; p.
Alexander Baring, who represented the banking houses
92, para 4, line 1, Ashur read
d Asher; p. 97, para 2, line 11,
of Baring Brothers and Hope and Company of London.
line 17, usually read unusually;
Baring is better known as Lord Ashburton, who, with
judgment; p. 101, para 2, line
Daniel Webster, negotiated the treaty settling Maine's
1, Kamph read Kramph. [The
northeastern boundary. For an excellent history of the
Owen for the above errors
Bingham Lands see the two volume work, William
3']
121-161
Maine Historical Socrety Quarterly 17,#3 (1978).
WOODLAWN
M u S E u M
The Black House
MAINE'S PREMIER HISTORIC ESTATE
Summer 2006
A Property of the Hancock County Trustees of Public Reservations
vol. 3 no. 3
Curious George: Woodlawn's Enigmatic Benefactor
by Jane Goodrich
On the frosty morning of November 1, 1928, the
citizens of Hancock County awoke to find they had been
given a marvelous gift. A few days earlier, on October
29, George Nixon Black, Jr. had died in his Beacon Street
home in Boston of the effects of arteriosclerosis. 1 He was 86
years old. In a will in which Mr. Black had painted a dozen
institutions with a very charitable brush, his hometown had
not been forgotten.² Woodlawn now belonged to everyone.
It was an astonishing final act, but one which had been
foreshadowed. Thirty years earlier, in 1897, Mr. Black
had gifted Ellsworth with a new library remodeled from
the handsome Tisdale house, another jewel in the city's
architectural crown.
Although George Nixon Black, Jr. had lived in Boston
for nearly 70 years he always cherished his Maine roots.
Woodlawn, along with its furnishings and history, was
probably his most valued possession. He relished his summer
visits to Ellsworth where he indulged in his horses, dogs,
parties and antiquing trips.3 When needed, he remodeled
and decorated Woodlawn with great care, judiciously
adding objects that reflected his colonial revival tastes but
wisely leaving the furnishings chosen for the house by his
grandparents, John and Mary Black, in place. He enjoyed
telling the stories of his great-grandfather General David
Cobb's role in the Revolutionary War, and especially prized
General Cobb's close connection to George Washington.
George Arim Black
That he conceived of Woodlawn as a museum and public
park is no surprise, as he desired to keep his family history
Photo of George Nixon Black, Jr., circa 1864, from
alive.
Woodlawn collections.
Yet, due either to humility or design, his own history is
strikingly absent. Woodlawn contains thousands of letters,
Continued on page 3...
Curious George (continued from page 1)
business records, deeds and travel journals, but fewer than
a dozen were penned by George, Jr. A small collection of
historic photographs exists, but there are more prints and
paintings representing George Washington in the Woodlawn
collection than there are pictures of the George who
bequeathed it. In fact, George, Jr. has SO successfully slipped
behind the curtain of his own ancestry that today few people
know he was never called George at all. To distinguish him
from his father he was always called Nixon.
Nixon was born July 11, 1842 in Ellsworth. He was
the second child and the only son of George Nixon Black,
Sr. and his wife, Mary Peters Black. He was educated by
private tutors, often along with his sisters, Marianne and
Agnes Black. When he was eleven he took dancing lessons
and he may have had some painting and drawing lessons as
well. In 1860, when he was 18 years old, he moved with
his family to Pemberton Square on Beacon Hill in Boston.
It must have been an amazing change for a young man of
artistic sensibilities after growing up in small-town Maine.
At the time, Boston was the fifth largest city in the United
States with a population just under 180,000.4
Miniature portrait of George Nixon Black, Jr., painted by
Boston was also undergoing great physical change.
Laura Coombs Hills. Woodlawn Museum collections.
The area north and west of Beacon Hill where the family
lived is today tree-lined and quaint, but was, in 1860, one
that a man take a military part in the war but many students
huge construction site. The massive work project of filling
from both the North and the South left Harvard to join their
the Back Bay began in 1858 just west of the present Boston
respective forces. The nation was in a tumult. Financial
Public Garden. In those years 35 train cars, loaded with
markets were in a panic. Nothing would ever be the same.
gravel were making the 9-mile run from a quarry in West
It took a steady hand and an astute eye to negotiate
Needham, every hour, twenty-four hours a day, six days a
a real estate business through these years of exaggerated
week.5 This filling continued (although at a slower pace)
growth and crisis, but fortunately George Nixon Black, Sr.
for the next 36 years, finally finishing in 1894 in the Fens
possessed both. Determined and painfully hard working,
near the present Boston Museum of Fine Arts. Houses
the elder Black had grown the wealth left to him by his
and shops were built on this "new land" almost as quickly
own father's businesses to a size never dreamed of by the
as it was leveled and graded, and a great migration of the
first generation. Following Nixon's failure to matriculate
population of Boston was underway. Derided at the time
at Harvard, and after allowing his son a year of travel in
by Henry James "as a tract pompous and prosaic", it was in
Europe, George, Sr. brought Nixon into the family business.
the Back Bay that Nixon's generation of men "established
The two men worked together for the next 14 years building
Boston as one of the centers of world culture in the arts and
a commercial real estate empire.
sciences.'
It is difficult to imagine how a young man interested
It was also a frightening time. Nixon entered Harvard
in art, history and horses took to the drudgery of real estate
College in the fall of 1860 but he had trouble there and
work. We know very little of Nixon's life during these
attended for less than a year. The Civil War had broken out
years, but it seems that he accepted his duty and did his best
and although Nixon did not enlist, many students dropped
to work well at it. Small glimpses of the man he was to
out at this time and classes were half-empty with their
become are evidenced in two contemporary letters. In one,
departure. The culture of the time by no means insisted
Nixon's interest in, and expertise on the opera are spoken
3
Curious George
(continued from page 5)
kept a detailed diary of her sitters and it is no surprise that
a Harvard education and then later endowed libraries. A
Nixon was one of her first, as well as one of the few men she
curious blend of humility and fierceness, he had both the
painted (see image on page 3). Nixon's mother also sat for
courage to insist upon his unconventional life and the
her own miniature, but it is Nixon's that is the most striking.
humility to commemorate it in the simplest manner possible
Hearty, happy and with vivid blue eyes and a stylish fur coat
on his tiny marble headstone at Mt. Auburn Cemetery in
he smiles out at us from the small oval of ivory as one of
Cambridge, Massachusetts.
the finest male miniature subjects Hills ever painted. This
Yet, it was as a patron that Nixon was his most singular.
commission tells more than the story of Nixon's love for
Possessed of the confidence and discrimination to recognize
the colonial revival. It speaks also of his support for all
talent, and yet restrained enough not to meddle with it, he
artists, male or female. In fact, of the two portraits Nixon is
was responsible for breathing life into several enduring
known to have commissioned of himself, both were made
pieces of art. His greatest genius may well have been the
by female artists.
ability to coax not only good work from his artist friends,
On November 11, 1904 events occurred which led to
but their best work.
Nixon's last great gift to the artistic and cultural community
in his lifetime. On this day a disastrous fire swept through
1
Death certificate October 29, 1928 Massachusetts State
Archives
the Harcourt Building of artists' studios, located just west
2
Will- George Nixon Black, Jr. Suffolk County Courthouse,
of Art Square. Several artists barely escaped with their
Boston, Massachusetts
lives and many others, including such notables as William
3
Manchester Breeze, July 21, 1906
M. Paxton and Joseph DeCamp, had their life's work
4
When in Boston, A Time Line & Almanac, Jim Vrabel,
destroyed. Almost immediately, a group of prominent
Bostonian Society 2004
5
When in Boston, A Time Line & Almanac, Jim Vrabel,
artists approached a group of prominent businessmen and
Bostonian Society, 2004
the Fenway Studios Trust was born. Working quickly,
6
Quoted from Lewis Mumford
architects engineered a studio building that the artists had
7
Woodlawn Museum Archives.
designed, and subscriptions were solicited to raise funds for
8 Facts About Trinity Stained Glass, Trinity Church, 2004.
the new structure. In just three months two trustees and
9 Cape Ann Advertiser, January 18, 1884
10 Diaries of Robert Swain Peabody, Boston Architectural
fourteen subscribers had raised the money and donated
Center, Boston, Massachusetts
the land. Of course, Nixon signed on as a subscriber at
11 Official Programme Peabody Essex Phillips Library, Salem,
the onset. Amazingly, the new building was finished and
Massachusetts
occupied within a year of the Harcourt fire. The artist
12 Laura Coombs Hills, A Retrospective- Historical Society of
occupants who used the building were among America's
Old Newbury, 1996
13 Fenway Studios, The Evolution of an Artist's Community in
most famous, and teachers from the Museum School used
Boston, Nancy Allyn Jarzombeck, 1998
the studios for classes. Fenway Studios remain today as
they were intended, fully occupied by a new generation of
artists plying their trade. 13
In the end, biography always falls short. The subject,
aided by the silt of time still manages to elude our grasp.
Nixon remains a delightful enigma. In 1842 when he
was born, the northern border of the state of Maine had
barely been settled with New Brunswick. It would take a
GEORGE
remarkable youth to develop a love of art while growing up
NIXON
in a place where he barely saw it, and a strong swimmer to
get from the icy, frontier waters of the Downeast coast to the
BLACK
important artistic and intellectual currents of his time.
So too, his powers of observation and self-interrogation
must have been notable. He was after all, a man who declined
10
FILE NO. record
HALE AND DORR
ORIGINAL FILE COPY
NOT TO LEAVE THE OFFICE
#3
60 State Street
Boston, Massachusetts
March 24, 1933
A. H. Lynam, Esq.
Bar Harbor, Maine
Dear Mr. Lynam:
As we are taking up again the question of the
Bingham Trustees and their records with special reference
to the Black House, I dictate from memory this picture of
the situation which I will revise and have ready for you
at such time in May as you may need it.
Hanpock County, Mt. Desert Island, and the Bingham
Trustees have a rich and interesting history and there are
many records of it. There is no place in the nature of a
public library or museum at the present time which has any
equipment for receiving and making available such records.
If you wanted to see an old record of the Bingham Trustees
or an old chart of the shore of the island in the early days,
or the records of some first settler, you would be hard put
to it to find a place in which two or three such things had
been gathered together and there is no place in which any
considerable quantity of such things could be properly handled.
On the other side, it is equally clear that there is
only one right place for such a museum. The history of the
Bingham Trustees and of their agents the Blasks and of the
HALE AND DORR
ORIGINAL FILE COPY
A. H. Lynam, Esq.
the TO LEAVE THE OFFICE
Black House make that estate the correct place for such a
museum. It is at the county seat, it is accessible from
all parts of the county, and it begins with the Black
records which are themselves of absorbing interest and
require arrangement and development.
Under those circumstances Mrs. Beatrix Farrand,
who is heartily in favor of the project I am outlining,
has caused Mr.
to study with her what will be
an adequate museum building. Mrs. Farrand has determined
upon its proper site. The site is interesting in itself
because the old Bingham agent used to gase on the mountains
of Mt. Desert Island from his house. But the trees of his
exit avenue now ecneeal that, Just beyond them toward
Surry is a field which is the ideal site for the missum
and from its southern windows the beautiful old view of
the island is restored.
I shall be sending you with this letter the plan
and a picture of the proposed building, Briefly it provides
for a miseum room (not unlike Sawtelle's in opportunity for
display) for proper fireproof storage, and for one or two
cubicles or other places adequate for research, study, and
preparation of material. Such a building would have sub-
stantially no depreciation, it would have no extra upkeep
cost. The Black House is gravely underendoved at the present
time and some additional endowment would make matters
safer.
FILE NO.
HALE AND DORR
ORIGINAL FILE COPY
NOT TO LEAVE THE OFFICE
A. H. Lynam, Esq. -3-
To such a building there should be transported,
First, all the miscellaneous material for
the history of the county including the island and the park.
Second, the contents of the Black House safe
which is not, from modern fireproof notions, a safe at all.
Third, the Hanoock County records of the
Bingham Trustees which according to my information are in
a safe in some vacant store in Ellsworth today. No one can
see them.
Perhaps the best example of the benefit which
would arise from what I am recommending is the story of the
Peters plan and the Peters notebook. The actual original
Peters plan of Mt. Desert Island is one of those records.
It was made by Peters from surveys which are recorded in
notebooks, Those notebooks themselves contain exciting
and interesting material for the history of the island.
Substantially all the titles on Mt. Desert Island
derive from that Peters
A particular instance of this is in order here.
On the old Sibley Richardson farm in the little village in
the town of Mt. Desert called by the picturesque name of
Sound is the site of the second saw mill erected upon Mt.
Desert Island. Mr. Hamlin has told me that the Peters note-
books contain his record of his day's journeys on the day
when he was survey tagtWemeand the record that his instrument
was set up for the purpose of surveying on the site of that
FILE NO.
HALE AND DORR
ORIGINAL FILE COPY
NOT TO LEAVE THE OFFICE
A. H. Lynam, Esq.
saw mill. The Richardsons and their sudnessors in the
ownership of that farm have preserved a parallel tradition
describing just how Peters came there that day and how
they told him that the saw mill was metherie handwrite used it
as the point of departure for his surveys.
If this information comes from accident, think
what more would come from study
(The first saw mill was that belonging to Mr. Bomes
on the brook at Somesville, And the lie that will not down
about Talleyrand being born on Mt. Desert Island mist be
located there in the Somes or in the Richardson families
and at one or the other of these sites. The vital records
of those families are seriously inconsistent with the myth.)
The next bajaht of these records 18 those in the
possession of the Bingham Trustees in Pennsylvania.
Now the first step toward having an adequate massum
is to get this great bulk of stuff to put into it, The time
is just ripe for that.
The Bingham Trustees in Hancock County and on
Mt. Desert Island have substantially completed their sales.
At the present moment they are paying taxes only on two items.
A. The great swamp or marah on Great Cranberry
Island assessed, I think, for $1,000. Its boundaries are
uncertain, it has no value for summer development, it ought
to be in public ownership.
FILE NO.
HALE AND DORR
ORIGINAL FILE COPY
A. H. Lynam, Esq. NOT TO LEAVE THE OFFICE
B. The land on the sea side of the Schooner Head
road about two miles out of Bar Harber lying between the
estate of Mr. Potter Palmer and the estate of Mrs. Merris
Hawkes.
of course that is not all to which the Bingham
Trustees have paper title. They are automatically the
residuary legatees of the Mt. Desert Island title and
again and again some example turns up indicating that a
release deed is desirable.
Specific instances of this are the Island of
Thrumcap title to which derives under a Bingham release
deed. Also rarious places where old deeds mentioning
high water mark only and deed to low water mark was in
order.
Then there are islets and ledges which being "in
front" of Mt. Desert are part of the Louis XIV grant which
controls the definition of the Bingham area. For a guess
the bar between Bakers Island and Little Cranberry Island
may well be found to be Bingham property. It has no com-
mercial value but it has grave importance from the point of
view of getting into public ownership areas which might other-
wise be abused. The excavation of the gravel from the "nubbin"
on that bar would be a public injury.
Back in the woodland of the county there are lots
of land to which the Bingham Trustees have paper title but
which they have long since ceased to carry for tax purposes.
FILE NO.
HALE AND DORR
ORIGINAL FILE COPY
A. H. Lynam, Esq. -for TO LEAVE THE OFFICE
Probably these will be found in the actual adverse owner-
ship of others who should have released 11 that is the case.
But if abandoned under adverse titles, it would be good for
the county to have these the property of the reservations,
In my opinion after one has extinded the Cranberry
marsh and the Schooner Head Road property;andvery small sum
if any would amply compensate the Bingham Trustees. I
believe they take part and Mr. Hamlin takes part of the
consideration of each release deed.
I do not believe that the Binghan part of these
release deeds more than pays for the cost of keeping up
the organization and taking care of the papers and knowing
what is going on about Hancock County, Maine.
Professor Samuel Eliot Morison, who goes to
Seal Cove in the summer and is one of the active men in
the Colonial Society of Mansachusettn, is ready to make
progress with the development of these records when they are
available.
For instance, he would be likely to require a
research student to camp in Ellsworth during the summer season
and write 2 thesis upon the Bingham Trustees, the Captain Black
agency, or even perhaps the relationship of Colonel John Black
to the Ashburton treaty and the international boundary disputes.
I submit that for a very moderate expenditure for
building, perhaps additional endowment, and the Bingham records
a public service could be date of romantia interest and
importance.
FILE NO.
HALE AND DORR
ORIGINAL FILE COPY
NOT TO LEAVE THE OFFICE
A. H. Lynam, Esq.
The panic of 1837 can be traced in many interest
ing developments in Colonel Black's letter book and other
papers.
Your a very truly,
RICHARD W. HALE
Richard #. Hale.
B.E.K.
MAR 24 1933
Viewer Controls
Toggle Page Navigator
P
Toggle Hotspots
H
Toggle Readerview
V
Toggle Search Bar
S
Toggle Viewer Info
I
Toggle Metadata
M
Zoom-In
+
Zoom-Out
-
Re-Center Document
Previous Page
←
Next Page
→
HCTPR Woodlawn-Black House
Details
Series 5